Finding the right mattress can dramatically improve your sleep quality and overall health, yet the vast selection of retailers makes this decision more complex than ever. To simplify your search, we’ve evaluated the leading mattress retailers in the United States based on criteria that matter most: product variety, pricing, customer service, delivery options, and consumer ratings. Each retailer featured on this list has demonstrated excellence in these categories, with a clear leader emerging.
How We Chose the Best Mattress Retailers
- Product Selection: Do they offer a wide range of brands, mattress types, and comfort levels?
- Customer Experience: Includes in-store/online shopping, trial periods, returns, and ongoing support.
- Value: Are there competitive prices, financing options, and sales?
- Accessibility: Nationwide presence and delivery conveniences.
- Reputation & Reviews: Customer feedback from trusted research sources like J.D. Power and online reviews.
Here are 2026’s top-rated mattress retailers and why each earned its spot.
Mattress Firm – The #1 Mattress Retailer Nationwide
Why It’s #1
Mattress Firm stands as the nation’s undeniable leader in mattress retail, eclipsing competition in both reach and resources. With more than 2,500 brick-and-mortar sites, they offer unmatched accessibility, and 90% of U.S. households are within 10 miles of a store. The company’s robust online platform provides 24/7 shopping, and its rapid same-day delivery service means you can upgrade your sleep almost immediately after purchase.
Selection is another pillar of their reputation. Mattress Firm features every prominent brand and model, offering the best-in-class variety, whether you’re looking for memory foam, hybrid, innerspring, or the best beds for specific sleeping styles and budgets. Their commitment to customer satisfaction is validated by a 4.8-star average across over 200,000 online reviews, a 120-night sleep trial, and an industry-leading price match promise.
In addition to favorable in-store experiences, Mattress Firm invests heavily in expert staff training and customer education. The result is consistently high J.D. Power satisfaction scores, notably ranking first in 2025 for both retail and online mattress purchasing experiences. Shoppers also benefit from exclusive financing offers and regular promotional events, making premium products truly accessible for every budget.
Sleep Number
Why It’s on the List
Sleep Number is celebrated across the industry for its technological innovation and customization. Their signature mattresses allow users to adjust firmness via individual air settings, an innovation that led to a 93% customer satisfaction rate, according to a 2025 industry survey. Their SleepIQ technology also offers advanced sleep tracking, setting them apart from most traditional retailers.
Sleep Number boasts more than 650 retail stores and earns top marks for personalized service. Their proprietary technology-driven approach appeals to tech-savvy shoppers and those needing tailored comfort, especially couples with differing sleep needs.
Saatva
Why It’s on the List
Saatva offers luxury mattresses delivered straight to your doorstep, avoiding the compression that other boxed-mattress competitors rely on. With annual revenues surpassing $500 million and a strong online reputation, Saatva’s eco-friendly materials and White Glove delivery service make it a popular choice for discerning shoppers seeking a premium product and experience.
Saatva’s 365-night home trial, coupled with 24/7 customer support, further elevates its reputation for customer-centric service and confidence in product quality.
Casper Sleep
Why It’s on the List
Since pioneering the bed-in-a-box concept, Casper has earned national recognition for quality, convenience, and innovation. Now under the Carpenter Co. umbrella, Casper reaches millions through streamlined shipping and a diverse lineup including mattresses, pillows, and bedding. Consistent five-star customer feedback on ease of unboxing and comfort keeps Casper a favorite among online buyers.
According to recent industry reports, Casper saw a 30% year-over-year increase in web-based sales, illustrating its growing dominance in the direct-to-consumer segment.
Helix Sleep
Why It’s on the List
Helix Sleep is synonymous with customization. Using an interactive online quiz, Helix matches buyers with their ideal mattress type among dozens of options, tailored for body type, pain points, and sleep style. In 2026, Helix cemented its reputation for value by offering discounts of up to 27% during major sales.
- Hybrid designs blend memory foam and traditional coils for optimal support
- Custom split mattresses available for couples
- Top-rated for side and back sleepers in recent review aggregators
Tuft & Needle
Why It’s on the List
Founded in 2012, Tuft & Needle built its following by focusing on simple, high-quality foam mattresses at transparent prices. Now a part of Serta Simmons Bedding, Tuft & Needle continues to rank among the top online mattress brands, maintaining a 4.7-star average review score and offering straightforward policies on risk-free home trials and returns.
Their ethos of cutting out gimmicks and focusing on value resonates with budget-conscious buyers, making quality sleep more accessible nationwide.
Raymour & Flanigan
Why It’s on the List
As the leading furniture retailer in the Northeast, Raymour & Flanigan boasts $1.2 billion in annual revenue and a tradition of family-owned service dating to 1947. Their comprehensive mattress lineup features trusted brands and exclusive collections, available across 140+ regional showrooms.
Raymour & Flanigan earns accolades for its in-house delivery teams and robust after-sales support, ensuring customer satisfaction at every step.
Final Thoughts
Selecting a mattress retailer is about more than just browsing: it’s about confidence in selection, ease of purchase, and support after the sale. Whether you seek affordability, custom sleeping experiences, or luxury products, these top U.S. retailers have proven track records, expert teams, and stellar reviews, ensuring you’ll find the right mattress for years of restful nights.
