Why People Hold Onto Certain Freebies and Throw Away Others

person keeping promotional gift items on desk

If you spend enough time either at conferences, local events, or with brand activations you’ll notice something pretty quickly. Certain free items find their way home in someone’s bag or on their office desk. Others get tossed before the day is even over. That disparity of outcomes has nothing to do with fate, and it’s not so much about brand recognition, either.

It’s about whether it comes home with someone because it fits into their life.

The Decision Made in a Matter of Seconds

There comes a moment—typically within seconds—of receiving something free where a silent judgment is made. Is this useful? Does it have a place in their day? While most would not be able to say they’ve made that decision in the moment, we all make it time and time again. We keep what passes. We discard what doesn’t, often at the first available opportunity.

What many businesses fail to recognize in the power of presentation is why their item should be so eye-catching without questioning whether it’s truly worth keeping. It’s easy to garner attention at face value for a second. It’s much harder to earn a standing place in someone’s life.

Usefulness Trumps Creativity Every Time

Items that stand the test of time get kept because they solve a problem, even if it’s a small one. A tote bag that doesn’t rip. A notebook that feels good with a pen in hand. A water bottle that keeps ice from melting. These are things people reach for without thinking and every time they do, they re-observe the branding on the outside.

Businesses that recognize this endeavor tend to spend money on items with staying power instead of ones designed to pop from a table. Simply Merchandise’s products reflect this way of thinking as they boast everyday, reliable type options over fleeting, out-of-the-box choices. There’s a more thoughtful approach there, and in the end, it shows.

The Cost of Going Cheap

While ordering bulk at the lowest price point for any item is highly appealing, especially if there is a large number, there’s a true cost to giving items that easily break. Stitching comes undone. Clips snap off. Ink runs dry after a week. These things make people take note, just not for the right reasons.

Sometimes it’s done under the radar but people notice. They don’t say anything but they know. They feel the flimsy material as it’s placed in their hands and that reaction is attributed with whatever brand it represents.

A quality item that lasts a year or two does much more silent heavy lifting than an inexpensive option getting tossed within days after a patron gets up close and personal with it. Breaking down the math makes even more sense when presented this way for more per unit charge equals less items treated as trash.

The Role of Relevance

Even still, an item can fall victim to being misplaced should it’s presented to the wrong person. A coffee mug given to someone who drinks water won’t likely end up on their desk just as much as the same cup given to someone who drinks coffee every day would likely earn its keep.

Businesses that garner the most from merchandise tend to think about their audience before they’ve made any decisions at all. What does this person need? What fits into their day? These are not long questions to consider but they’re often overlooked entirely by businesses.

Quality Without Qualifying Your Position

For every time someone picks up an item that branding is attributed through a small instant impression created through the lens of the brand behind it, and reinforced or undermined by whatever happens next. A well-made item stands the test of time, silently asserting that the company behind it values quality. Something that falls apart suggests otherwise.

Branded merchandise does not exist independent of its maker. The reputation follows and its quality becomes part of how that reputation is received every single time someone interacts with it.

The Gimmicky Trap

Items shaped like something unexpected or possessing features that sound cool but rarely get used get an instantaneous hit and little else. No one keeps them around long after the fact once the excitement dies down and there’s nothing else keeping it in rotation.

Merchandise that earns its place in someone’s life over months and years are usually the simplest forms: a well-structured notebook, a cohesive pen, a tote bag that stands upright without help, or well-designed versions of those options. They don’t need to be clever; they just need to be good. That’s worth visibility long after the conference or event has ended.

Timing Is Everything

Even if something is genuinely useful if the timing is wrong it will end up forgotten or shoved aside within the frenzy of excitement. Handing something to someone mid-conversation or while they’re juggling multiple bags is likely going to have it set down forgotten about before it even gets home.

Items gifted as welcome packs, incorporated in orders or given at a relaxed moment during an event have much better odds of sticking around as appreciation happens in real time and concern for appearance occurs as much as recipient response does. The manner in which something is given matters just as much as what’s being conveyed within it.

What Gets Kept?

Once you start looking for a pattern, it’s pretty consistent over time if you’re educated in recognizing it. The things that get kept are typically helpful, well-made and relevant to the owner in question at the time they have access to it—they do not rely on gimmicks to get their place kept; they earn it through continued use—and that continued use is precisely why they’re worth so much investment..

There’s also something to be said for restraint: if a business gives away one well-planned item it’s more impactful than dumping ten inexpensive options and hoping one or two sticks to the wall as the proverbial saying goes.

Finding this sweet spot isn’t about paying more across all boards; it’s about careful selection and maintaining a focus on what’s important for recipient use rather than what’s aesthetically pleasing on an order form.

Leave a Reply